Pumpkin Cheese Ball Recipe Michelle Buffardi. With a mixer, blend 1. Scoop onto plastic wrap and use the wrap to form the mixture into a 5 inch pumpkin shaped ball chill at least 2 hours. To serve, unwrap, roll in crushed nacho flavored tortilla chips and press a bell pepper stem into the top. Photograph by Sam Kaplan. Add butter mixture to combine with the rum. Dont rush it. Slowly add water, stirring as you pour. Drop in a cinnamon stick for an extra kick. You are going to love this Jello Shot Christmas Tree Recipe. We have 70 jello shot ideas plus video directions to show you how to make your own at home. Beef Fondue Dipping Sauces.